Minutes from Executive Council Meetings

March 2007

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL MINUTES

March 5, 2007

Present: Rev. Gordon Forbes, Rev. Sandy Dodson, Aldene Ault, Judy Cox, Bud Dennie, Sue Dollins, Trish Esposito, Stevan Fisher, John Gipson, Pete Hotchkiss, Karen Lee, Cynthia Page, Dan Pence, Doris Raber, Kate Rogers, Anne Weissenborn, Leslie Weyn, Tim White.  Guests:  Bill Neal, Neville Platt.

Rev. Gordon Forbes called the meeting to order at approximately 7:35 p.m.  He opened the meeting with a time of silence and prayer.

Anne Weissenborn reminded all boards to submit minutes of their meetings to the office.  After brief discussion, it was agreed that submission via e-mail would be sufficient, with no need to submit a paper copy.

The Council approved the minutes for the February meeting, as presented.

Board and Committee Updates

  1. Interim Search Committee—Rev. Gordon Forbes reported that the membership of the Interim Search Committee has been finalized.  The members are:  Jim Walters, Holly Brooks, Marilyn Hall, Don Collins, and Jean Naryannan.  The Committee has met with Conference Minister John Deckenback.  The Committee will begin gathering information on prospective candidates.  The Committee hopes to begin receiving names of prospective interims by April 1.  To begin with, the denomination will forward three dossiers to the Committee.  The Committee will also seek candidates from outside the denomination.  The Committee is also open to considering candidates referred by the congregation.  The Committee has set as its goal to have an interim in place by September 1.  The Committee will keep the congregation informed of its progress.
  1. Senior Adults—Rev. Gordon Forbes reported that the Senior Adult Committee met with CCC lay leadership and ministers on March 4.  Gordon reported that the senior adults are well-organized and have a clear goal.  They want a staff position funded at greater than 10 hours per week.  They would prefer that the position be filled by an ordained individual.  However, they are very happy with the job that Sarah Anders is doing, and Sarah is on an ordination track.  Sarah is willing to continue in the position for two years, at a minimum of 10 hours per week and to volunteer for additional hours to meet the ordination requirements of Wesley Theological Seminary.  Gordon characterized the senior adults as feeling that their needs were somewhat minimized in the recent visioning process.  Neville Platt explained that the senior adults felt that their needs had been recognized in prior visioning, but felt that the structure of the most recent visioning meeting resulted in their needs being minimized.  He said the group felt strongly that the congregation should support an increase in hours for Sarah Anders.
  1. Endowment—Pete Hotchkiss reported that the Special Gifts Committee, consisting of Pete, Dave Ackerman, Toko Ackerman, Tom Ault, Dick Meyer, and Mary Stone, had been meeting at least once a month for over a year.  The Committee has completed its report, which will be presented to the Council at next month’s meeting.  The report includes recommendations that would require the amendment of CCC’s governing documents.
  1. Celebrations—Kate Rogers reported that a roast of Rev. Jim Todhunter is scheduled for 7:30 p.m. Friday, June 15, 2007, at the Silver Spring Hilton.  Hors d’oeuvres and dessert will be served, and a cash bar will be available.  The cost will be $30 per person.  The Hilton will make its shuttle van available if some of those attending wish to park at the church.  Sue Dollins reported that the banquet honoring Rev. Todhunter will be held from 6 p.m. to 10 p.m. on Saturday, July 14, 2007, at the Kirkland Center, located at the George Meany College of Labor on New Hampshire Avenue.  The cost for that event will be $50 per person.  Stevan Fisher reported that there will be an all-church picnic from 12 p.m. to 2 p.m. on Sunday, May 20, 2007, at the Silver Spring YMCA.  The Board for Church Life will cover the cost of the facility ($125) and will provide meats, buns/rolls, cups, and plates.  Other foods and beverages will be pot-luck.
  1. Retreat House Task Force—Trish Esposito reported that the members of the Task Force are: Rick Sniffen, Cory Gray, Susan Hill, John Enagonio, Larry Hanes, and Sarah Anders.  The role of the Task Force is to implement the vision created by the Retreat House Visioning Committee.
  1. Weekend Custodian—Bud Dennie reported that Joseph Slater was hired effective February 25.   Bud expressed thanks to Anne Weissenborn and Iona Hiland for their help in getting the new custodian on board.
  1. Personnel Committee—Bud Dennie reported that the Committee has drafted a new Safe Church Policy.  The Policy has been forwarded to the Board for Christian Education for its review.  Once the CE review is completed, the Policy will be forwarded to staff for review in May.  The Committee hopes that the Policy will be ready for approval in June.  Bud also reported that a team has been assembled to conduct the evaluation of Rev. Sandy Dodson.  The team consists of Rev. Jim Todhunter, Bud Dennie, Karen Lee, and Dave Ackerman.  The evaluation team will collect feedback on Sandy’s performance in two main ways.  The team has created a questionnaire that will be distributed to the congregation.  They will also conduct small group meetings with members of the congregation focusing on various aspects of Sandy’s ministry and leadership.  The evaluation team’s goal is to complete the evaluation process by May.  The Personnel Committee will also forward a proposed compensation package for Sandy to the Board of Trustees by April.  In response to a question, Bud clarified that Sandy’s compensation package is not tied to the results of her evaluation.  Bud and Karen Lee stressed that the evaluation process is a new one, so there will be a lot of learning that takes place for all participants in the process.  Sandy added that she is looking forward to what she understands will be a collaborative and “dialogical” process.
  1. Trustees—Tim White gave a progress report on the budget process and an early snapshot of the 2007-08 budget.  Tim said that the Board of Trustees has received all initial estimates.  The formal process is now beginning, Tim said.  He asked that Boards and Committees complete an updated budget form by April 1.  He stressed that it is important to be clear what the numbers are and how they were arrived at.  It is also important that the priorities of the Board or Committee are clear.  Tim reported that the preliminary submissions suggest that next year’s budget will require a 30 to 35% increase over the current budget.  Tim stated that the increases are driven by such factors as CCC’s dreams and aspirations for program growth, upkeep of the building, the work of the search committees, and servicing CCC’s debt.  The debt situation was eased in the current year due to a one-time carryover.  No funds of that sort are available this year, so we will have to cover the full cost of debt service.  Tim said that the 2007-08 budget will probably be finalized in late April or early May.

Physician Assistance in Dying

Bill Neal requested that the Executive Council put the proposed resolution on Physician Assistance in Dying before the congregation for a vote.  Bill reported that the resolution had been approved by both the Board for Social Witness and the Senior Adult Committee.  Bill explained that his passion about this issue was inspired by the plight of his father, who lived with Parkinson’s Disease for 17 years, and died slowly and painfully.  Bill expressed his belief that the theological basis for the resolution is that God’s will does not include suffering beyond endurance.  Bill proposed that his paper on physician assistance in dying be distributed to the congregation and then Bill would conduct question and answer sessions with interested members of the congregation.  Thereafter, Bill would like the congregation to vote on the resolution at a congregational meeting.  Rev. Gordon Forbes and Dan Pence both inquired what Bill’s purpose would be in having the congregation vote.  Bill responded that it was his hope to be able to bring his resolution to the Central Atlantic Conference having been adopted by CCC.  Gordon explained that the Central Atlantic Conference would not vote on the resolution before its 2008 meeting.  At the 2007 Conference meeting, Bill will be presenting a workshop on the issue.  It is Bill’s hope to bring the resolution to the General Synod in 2009.  Bill explained that he hopes to have a main line Protestant church endorse the concept of physician assistance in dying to counter the position of the Catholic Church, which opposes it.  There was discussion during which council members, including Cynthia Page, Rev. Sandy Dodson, and Rev. Gordon Forbes stressed the need to fully explore and explain the theological basis for supporting physician assistance in dying.  Trish Esposito pointed out that the congregation will need time to study and dialog about the issue.  Pete Hotchkiss pointed out that the Executive Council had previously asked Bill to bring the issue before the Board for Social witness, which he has done.  In that way, Pete said, Bill has jumped over the bar, and the Executive Council should act.  John Gipson said that, in his view, Bill didn’t need the Council’s permission to bring up the issue before the congregation.  Sue Dollins moved that the Council authorize Bill Neal to bring the issue of physician assistance in dying to a congregational meeting, to be preceded by educational opportunities that include discussion of Bill’s resolution, as well as the theological issues involved.  Aldene Ault seconded the motion.  The motion passed without objection. 

Structure of the Board for Christian Education

Karen Lee reported that, at the time the responsibility for adult education was transferred from the Board of Deacons to CE, the membership of the CE Board increased to 21.  This number of members has proved to be somewhat unmanageable, Karen said.  Therefore, the Board met with Rev. Sandy Dodson to discuss reorganization.  The result of that meeting is a proposal to change the membership of the Board from 21 to 12.  Sandy explained that 10 of the positions will be for rotating terms of 3 years, there will be one youth member serving a one-year term, and one young adult member, also serving a one-year term.  The focus areas for the Board will be:  Children, Youth, Young Adults/Adults/Family, and Camp.  Sandy said that adult education is seen as being self-directing on an ongoing basis.  Trish Esposito reported that Toko Ackerman had informed her that changing the membership of the CE Board requires a change to the CCC Bylaws.  Accordingly, Karen Lee moved that the Bylaws be amended to reflect that the membership of the Board for Christian Education is changed from 21 members to 12 members.  Dan Pence seconded the motion.  The motion passed without objection.

Volunteer Needs of CCC

Trish Esposito, as Chair of the Nominating Committee, reported that the task of recruiting volunteers is becoming overwhelming.  There are so many special task forces and committees, such as search committees, currently being staffed, that people are already feeling stretched thin.  In addition, a number of standing committees, such as Sanctuary, Referral and Service, Kitchen, and Buildings and Grounds are in great need of new members and leadership.  Moreover, it is a continuing struggle for CE to recruit teachers for Church School.  Dan Pence asked whether other Boards should down-size as CE decided to do.  He also wondered whether there were committees that should be sunsetted.  Trish said that the Nominating Committee has been looking at these issues, but that there were no immediate recommendations along these lines.  Trish encouraged Boards to try to identify discrete tasks that volunteers could undertake that would support the Board without the volunteer having to commit to being a full Board member.  Karen Lee and Stevan Fisher pointed to coffee service at fellowship time and preparing supper for youth group as examples of discrete tasks that volunteers may perform without being members of a Board.  Trish said that the Nominating Committee will try to identify members for committees as well as Boards.  Trish also announced that a representative of the Red Cross will make a presentation at CCC on volunteer recruitment.  Karen Lee observed that the difficulty of recruiting volunteers is a systemic issue at CCC.  Rev. Gordon Forbes suggested that this is an issue that would be appropriate for the Interim Search Committee to inquire about when interviewing candidates for Interim Minister.  Tim White suggested that perhaps we should have fewer Boards and Committees and instead organize around short-term, focused projects.  Aldene Ault expressed thanks for the year-round efforts of the Nominating Committee.  She also observed that the Board for Stewardship has had difficulty incorporating gifts of time and talent into the stewardship campaign.  Karen Lee pointed out that folks want to be asked to serve.  Trish agreed, but said that the process of asking can be a lengthy one, because of leaving messages and waiting to get called back.  Sue Dollins emphasized the need to be specific when asking someone to serve.  Trish agreed, and asked Boards to provide as much specific information as possible about their vacancies.

After evaluation of the meeting, Rev. Sandy Dodson closed the meeting with a prayer.

Rev. Gordon Forbes adjourned the meeting at 9:31 p.m.

Respectfully submitted,
Leslie Weyn
Church Clerk

Other Council Meeting Minutes

Return to CCC Home Page